KYLIE JENNER MAY HAVE COST TIMOTHÉE CHALAMET AN OSCAR, AWARDS VOTER SAYS

Newsweek Exclusive Feature

Insiders told Newsweek that timing, image and Academy instincts—not viral outrage or Chalamet’s talent—may be to blame.

The internet has been bubbling over with theories about how Timothée Chalamet—Hollywood’s golden boy, three times nominated for Best Actor and still ascending—managed to miss out on an Oscar, yet again. Was it the clip? The vibe? The girlfriend? Or the growing sense he was being crowned too soon?

Amid a flurry of hot takes and TikTok breakdowns, one thing is missing—a clear-eyed postmortem that dissects both the voting timeline and the Academy's cultural underbelly.

Two awards-season veterans who watch these races up close say the answer is less about scandal than structure, and attribute Chalamet's loss to narrative and the Academy's perception of stardom.

Walter Nicoletti, founder and CEO of film production and distribution firm Voce Spettacolo, told Newsweek that the most widely shared explanation for Chalamet’s loss does not even match the awards season calendar.

"While all media suggests Chalamet's dismissive comments about 'ballet and opera' cost him the Oscar, the timeline of the Academy voting cycle tells a different story," Nicoletti said. "Oscar voting closed on March 5, 2026 at 5 p.m. PT, and the clip of his comments didn't go viral until the evening of March 5 and throughout that weekend."

That distinction matters, because it reframes what has become Chalamet’s third Best Actor loss not as a self-inflicted wound, but as a more-complicated collision of timing and taste.

Chalamet had sparked backlash after saying in a CNN-Variety town hall that he did not want to work in ballet or opera because they are art forms "no one cares about anymore," comments he later said were meant flippantly and followed by a show of respect to those fields.

A Career on the Rise

Still in the early stages of his career, Chalamet has already secured three Best Actor nominations, a rare feat that positions him as something of a prodigy. Each nomination has reinforced the sense that, for the 30-year-old, an Oscar is not a question of if, but when. And yet, once again, the statuette slipped through his fingers.

Timothée Chalamet and Kylie Jenner attend the 98th Annual Oscars at Dolby Theatre on March 15, 2026 in Hollywood, California. Credit: GETTY IMAGES

"I think that the controversy created only a negative halo that made the loss feel deserved to the general public and audience," Nicoletti said. "Voters often recoil when they feel a young actor is being crowned too early."

In that context, Chalamet’s campaign, energized by a Golden Globe win, may have peaked too soon.

"While Chalamet was doing a victory after his Golden Globe win, Michael B. Jordan's performance hit its peak momentum at exactly the right time," Nicoletti said. "I think that Jordan offered a cleaner story for all the voters while Chalamet offered a more stylized, eccentric

story with his character Marty Mauser."

The Burden of Visibility

There is also the question of image, an increasingly fraught terrain for actors navigating fame in an era of constant exposure and social-media intrigue.

"While the Academy is becoming younger and more progressive, a significant portion of the voting block still values the mystery of a leading man," Nicoletti said.

In Chalamet’s case, that mystery has arguably been eroded by his omnipresence beyond the screen. Nicoletti said that the actor’s high-profile personal life, particularly constant public appearances with his celebrity girlfriend Kylie Jenner, may have subtly shifted how he is perceived.

"The prestige of his performance has been toned down by the constant presence of his girlfriend," Nicoletti said. "This particular situation making him feel more like a celebrity than a craftsman in the eyes of the old guard of the Academy members.

"For example, Leonardo DiCaprio is always very careful to protect his image: this year, he was alone on the red carpet because it's a strategic image management in the entertainment industry."

That strategy aligns with what Nicoletti describes as a "classic star text," one that emphasizes seriousness and craft over gossip-driven visibility and tabloid cycles.

In that framework, Chalamet’s growing cultural relevance and public romance may have unfairly blunted the prestige of his performance in the eyes of more-traditional voters.

Debra Caruso Marrone, the longtime owner of media relations firm DJC Communications, told Newsweek that she sees the contest through a different lens, one that is performance first.

"Having seen most of the Oscar’s performances for best actor, I do believe Timothee Chalamet was robbed, maybe even because of his girlfriend," she said.

Though she did add that his "ballet and opera" comments may have been a factor in his loss.

Losing To Win

And yet, there is another way to read Chalamet's defeat: not as a setback, but as a safeguard.

"This third consecutive loss prevents Chalamet from becoming the kid who got everything too soon," Nicoletti said. "So he lost because he ran a perfect campaign in a year where the Academy decided they preferred the electric energy of Michael B. Jordan over the brilliance of a young king."

In Hollywood, timing is everything. Winning too early could freeze an actor in amber, inviting backlash, leading to internal pressure or unrealistic expectations. Losing—especially narrowly, repeatedly—can have the opposite effect, keeping hunger alive and sympathy intact among viewers and fans.

"This keeps Chalamet more hungry and keeps the industry rooting for him," Nicoletti added. "In Hollywood, sometimes you have to lose the battle to win the decade."

Newsweek reached out to Chalamet and Jenner for comment via email.

THANK YOU FOR READING

COVER IMAGE CREDIT: GETTY IMAGES

READ THE FULL STORY HERE: Kylie Jenner May Have Cost Timothée Chalamet an Oscar, Award’s Voter Says - Newsweek